Monday, November 7, 2011

WoW: The Great Item Squish

MMO-champion has a blue post on the homepage addressing problem that has been lurking in the background of WoW since the first expansion: For how long will stat / damage numbers continue to increase? It's an interesting problem, and I wonder what others think about the situation and how they would solve it. Blizzard offers two solutions:

1) Mega Damage: Damage and stats would continue to increase at exponential levels, but instead of a fireball doing 6,000,000 damage, it would do 6 MEGA DAMAGE.

2) Item Level Squish: Reduce all stats in the game (characters, mobs, bosses, gear) to more manageable levels.

1 seems like a silly solution. Why not just display the 6,000,000 damage number if a character does 6,000,000 damage? 2 seems sensible, but creates a problematic aesthetic for the gameworld. We already have the problem of greens replacing purples every expansion. Now we'd have another reversion of progress by lowering the numbers every few expansions. Right now with all of my stats I have, say, +7,000 to spell damage. It seems weird that a new expansion, offering progress and increase to my character, would also revert my numbers to put me at +700 or +70 spell damage.

The number reversion solution also creates an interesting compression problem at the lower end of the game. If the lowest level mobs in starting zones have, say, 50 health do we compress them down to 5, to keep them in scale with the high-end boss health decrease? If so, wouldn't this create a problem after two or three world-wide stat compressions?

Something to think / talk about if it interests you: If you created a game that utilized stat increase as a game mechanic, then how would you deal with the exponential increase in stats over time?

61 comments:

  1. It's a similar problem that always pissed me off about dragonball z. The numbers get to a point that they just don't make sense anymore in the universe in which they exist.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the final spirit bomb in Dragonball GT did something like double-infinite damage, and killed God, or some shit.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's the problem of MTG sets and power creep....

    Thing is, there, they've created a planned obsolescence scenario where they can scale power back for a series of sets, while the nuts stuff slides off Type 2.


    I wonder how that could be achieved in WoW without erasing or infrequent compression nerfs.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The difference is that MTG has set win conditions to which every expansion adds new means of attaining.

    Yes, they create new win conditions sometimes.

    But the general win condition is to lower one's opponent from 20 health to 0 health. It's not that every expansion adds 10 more health to the starting health pool, but rather it modifies that basic structure.

    That's different from WoW, wherein every expansion adds more health to the pools, more damage to characters (creatures in MTG).

    I realize that's all vague; it's meant to be.

    I think what I'd do to avoid the WoW squish situation is that insted of every expansion adding more numbers, keep the numbers vageuely the same but add new mechanics.

    So rather than adding new bosses whose health pools are exponentially higher than past bosses, keep bosses in the same general level of health but add new mechanics to new boss fights.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Here's another way of saying it: I don't like that I can solo Onyxia or Ragnaros; it seems very odd that Ragnaros dies in 4 hits whereas new bosses take so much more damage to kill.

    I'd like a game where bosses are constructed relative to one another in a sensible fashion, so Illidan doesn't become a pushover now that I've gained 10 more levels.

    ReplyDelete
  6. .... yes, buuuuut... Power and Toughness? Mana Cost-relative-to-Mana Production?

    Those don't change between sets anymore than DMG-Per-Sec. changes between expansions.

    Sure, different sets change the context in which these conditions apply, but the mechanics don't change their underlying functions... well... every sea-change of Six Sets or so, perhaps.

    New expansions don't modify the total health or the ways in which one can damage the other, they modify the quantity of damage done relative to the quantity of damage preventable. Via mana-production/casting speed and counter-measure-ry: counterpart creatures, direct damage, counter, control, whathaveyou.

    You would prefer subsequent WoW boss-beasties be roughly the same equivalent stat-wise, but have countermeasures that reduce/intervene the classic ways of increasing stats/grind. Which.. is what I was saying before.. MTG suffers the same problem but gets around it by continually shifting the context. Slowing down production/ diminishing general creature size/adding new wrinkle-rules that warp this set or that.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "You would prefer subsequent WoW boss-beasties be roughly the same equivalent stat-wise, but have countermeasures that reduce/intervene the classic ways of increasing stats/grind."

    Yes. Or, at least, that is what i'm saying in this argument.

    I think the problem is the exponential increase in power over time. At T1 40 persons are required to kill Ragnaros. At T2 one warlock in greens can kill Ragnaros.

    That seems problematic.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Agreed... but.. how do you deal with that, in a progressive system?

    Possibly statebased stats that rate characters upon entry to the instance/field/script/what-have-you?

    I mean.. they could go back and raise the old guys, Ragnaros etc.., leaving newcomers on the outside of experiencing the content..

    They could stomp stats down once in a while, like pushing down the trash in the bin to conserve bags.. pissing off folks because conceptually, you're taking things away from them, albeit for some greater good - See Skullclamp bannings, enraged seniors around Warsaw who hate socialists but will go to arms over losing social security or medicare or whathaveyou.


    Or finding some sort of hybrid solution.. and.. an elite-version of the same content with scaled up stats.. seems.. reasonable? Or am I missing a trick?

    ReplyDelete
  9. xcbi longchamp bags GiuWcx 8920
    longchamp outlet tesy http://www.longchampbagspurse.com/ longchamp outlet

    Bsfvn xgkqvz longchamp handbags 1589
    longchamp outlet tfvz http://www.longchamphandbagsusa.com/ longchamp outlet

    nuxv longchamp sale NthFj paris z 4804
    longchamp outlet tmdn http://www.longchampsalepurse.com/ longchamp outlet

    Ifinv pvqtsw longchamp le pliage awx7502
    longchamp outlet lzon http://www.longchamplepliageus.com/ longchamp outlet

    Ovwvt longchamp glcwnw
    Rit longchamp outlet xy tso longchamp paris jeo
    Kdyti longchamp tfdf long champ ra longchamp sale bejopz
    Rhh longchamp outlet hm nzm longchamp paris uli
    Htp longchamp le pliage vm longchamp jgt longchamp le pliage qdz
    Ned longchamp outlet tq jx longchamp bags h longchamp paris vui

    ReplyDelete
  10. rkhg longchamp bags RcbZhu 6048
    longchamp outlet ydfj http://www.longchampbagspurse.com/ longchamp outlet

    Dehdm eutclh longchamp handbags 4764
    longchamp outlet dbjh http://www.longchamphandbagsusa.com/ longchamp outlet

    hyvd longchamp sale WevHa paris j 5098
    longchamp outlet hczk http://www.longchampsalepurse.com/ longchamp outlet

    Wthbo uflopz longchamp le pliage zlm6231
    longchamp outlet apcz http://www.longchamplepliageus.com/ longchamp outlet

    Btaqg longchamp nnojrl
    Psq longchamp outlet hw koa longchamp paris pfz
    Urefq longchamp mhpo long champ cs longchamp sale dotloc
    Jha longchamp outlet bt swy longchamp paris buf
    Wdl longchamp le pliage qc longchamp gnl longchamp le pliage nfo
    Dns longchamp outlet ik mn longchamp bags c longchamp paris dlc

    ReplyDelete
  11. http://www.louisvuittonpursesusauk.com/ louis vuitton purses zotd louis vuitton bags AiiIjt 4335kvs
    wzakcsww louis vuitton wallet qpwy

    Omqgr jmacir louis vuitton handbags 7227
    yeumerhi louis vuitton belt mavx

    uzpo louis vuitton sale BxoMb paris v 4690
    ojsgnvngc louis vuitton purses bytz

    Nmoen yexbgh louis vuitton hne9559
    cierzuz louis vuitton outlet online pctd

    Nnrdi louis vuitton handbags yxgjne
    Auu louis vuitton outlet br ddm louis vuitton paris yhb
    Xeaws louis vuitton kjpp louis vuitton purse rr louis vuitton fagjty
    Xum louis vuitton outlet qn noz louis vuitton handbag fls
    Ped louis vuitton purses va louis vuitton mhq louis vuitton online store mgj
    Owd louis vuitton bags mt nn louis vuitton bags w louis vuitton belt zhx

    ReplyDelete
  12. http://camdengamers.com/members/usakiki/activity/44068

    http://projectfitfamilies.org/pff/groups/www-louisvuittonoutletonlinelove-com-gs110165/

    http://www.24-hrnetwork.com/networkwp/members/usamqbqrk/activity/93225

    http://www.rorygordonphoto.com/tradingpost/topic.php?id=168842&replies=1#post-170210

    http://www.mrmalo.com/forum/topic/wwwlouisvuittonwalletukusacom-mki520379?replies=1#post-277784

    http://bettermindconsulting.com/groups/www-louisvuittonoutletonlinelove-com-gs110117/

    http://www.rendsburger-symposien.de/forum/topic.php?id=13110&replies=1#post-14075

    http://www.nathanielrenton.com/ministicks/members/usazzhgid/activity/204094

    http://droidfiend.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=1262375&replies=1#post-1330162

    http://artbees.net/forum/topic.php?id=246421&replies=1#post-282974

    http://wow.recaon-gaming.com/node/96597

    http://www.movilizando.org/bbpress/topic.php?id=618032&replies=1#post-186324

    http://www.exhibitagallery.com/legionoftheblack/members/usallavxo/activity/108539

    http://www.riverbendcombat.com/drupal-6.20/node/101285

    http://good-message.pp.ua/forum/bbpress/topic.php?id=3334&replies=1#post-4720

    http://albusdent.ru/bbpress/topic.php?id=8735&replies=1#post-16979

    http://pypeline.com/forum/topic.php?id=2065&replies=1#post-3312

    http://www.saukliai.lt/forumas/topic/wwwlouisvuittonbeltnycom-sx550164?replies=1#post-263065

    http://ekstasisdance.com/community/topic.php?id=184706&replies=1#post-191626

    http://readr.ru/forum/topic.php?id=434&replies=1#post-468

    http://unamovil.unam.mx/node/37652

    ReplyDelete
  13. buy tramadol online ultram side effects withdrawal - buy tramadol online cod no prescription

    ReplyDelete
  14. alprazolam 0.5mg prilosec xanax drug interactions - xanax 1mg day

    ReplyDelete
  15. tramadol no prescription tramadol hcl premature ejaculation - order tramadol cash on delivery

    ReplyDelete
  16. buy tramadol online tramadol buy online cheap - tramadol 50 mg pills

    ReplyDelete
  17. buy tramadol online tramadol normal dosage - buy tramadol extended release

    ReplyDelete
  18. xanax online xanax effects neurotransmitters - xanax withdrawal buspar

    ReplyDelete
  19. buy carisoprodol carisoprodol mixed with alcohol - carisoprodol addiction withdrawal

    ReplyDelete
  20. carisoprodol 350 mg picture of carisoprodol 350 mg - cost of carisoprodol 350 mg

    ReplyDelete
  21. generic xanax number xanax overdose - buy xanax online legally cheap

    ReplyDelete
  22. buy tramadol online tramadol hcl 60 mg - tramadol addiction 2012

    ReplyDelete
  23. carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol dosage to get high - carisoprodol 350 mg forum

    ReplyDelete
  24. buy tramadol online dealing with tramadol addiction - tramadol 50 mg kaps

    ReplyDelete
  25. buy carisoprodol cheap carisoprodol 350 mg what is it used for - difference between soma carisoprodol

    ReplyDelete
  26. buy tramadol online tramadol 50mg to get high - tramadol overdose timeline

    ReplyDelete
  27. carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol 350 mg directions - carisoprodol long term use

    ReplyDelete
  28. buy cheap tramadol high off tramadol 50 mg - buy tramadol with paypal

    ReplyDelete
  29. generic xanax generic xanax weaker - overdose symptoms for xanax

    ReplyDelete
  30. buy carisoprodol carisoprodol soma wiki - order carisoprodol online

    ReplyDelete
  31. buy tramadol online order cheap tramadol-overnight - tramadol hcl street value

    ReplyDelete
  32. buy carisoprodol what is soma carisoprodol used for - carisoprodol 175 mg

    ReplyDelete
  33. buy cialis online cialis 100mg - average retail price cialis

    ReplyDelete
  34. order cialis from canada how does cialis daily work - cialis max dosage

    ReplyDelete
  35. buy tramadol online tramadol (ultram rx) - is tramadol hcl 50 mg an opiate

    ReplyDelete
  36. tramadol online no prescription tramadol 50 mg compared to vicodin - tramadol nausea

    ReplyDelete
  37. xanax online tips pass drug test xanax - xanax drug detection

    ReplyDelete
  38. cialis online cialis online consultation - cialis 5 mg online kaufen

    ReplyDelete
  39. buy cialis online safely buy cialis usa online - buy cialis new delhi

    ReplyDelete
  40. http://landvoicelearning.com/#21906 tramadol for dogs dosage - tramadol withdrawal vicodin

    ReplyDelete
  41. http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#73892 long does tramadol overdose last - buy tramadol online with american express

    ReplyDelete
  42. buy tramadol buy tramadol 50mg - tramadol hcl zydol 50mg

    ReplyDelete
  43. buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg and breastfeeding - tramadol hcl 50 mg high

    ReplyDelete
  44. tramadol online tramadol 50mg for dogs usa - tramadol for dogs constipation

    ReplyDelete
  45. learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol addiction more drug_warnings_recalls - tramadol zolpidem interaction

    ReplyDelete
  46. http://landvoicelearning.com/#21906 tramadol high feel like - tramadol 100mg used

    ReplyDelete
  47. buy tramadol tramadol ultram er - 100mg tramadol overdose

    ReplyDelete
  48. buy tramadol cod buy tramadol online australia no prescription - tramadol tolerance

    ReplyDelete
  49. http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#56411 can you buy tramadol over counter usa - tramadol 50mg not working

    ReplyDelete
  50. buy tramadol buy tramadol online mastercard - tramadol 50mg side effects

    ReplyDelete
  51. tramadol 50 buy-cheap-tramadol.org - tramadol 50 mg is equal to

    ReplyDelete
  52. buy tramadol online tramadol for dogs long term use - tramadol to buy online in usa

    ReplyDelete
  53. learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol 50mg pill - tramadol hcl 50 mg generic

    ReplyDelete
  54. buy tramadol online buy tramadol personal check - tramadol hcl long term use

    ReplyDelete
  55. http://blog.dawn.com/dblog/buy/#about-us cheap tramadol cod delivery - whats better tramadol ultram

    ReplyDelete
  56. generic lorazepam ativan toxicity - cheap ativan

    ReplyDelete
  57. buy tramadol tramadol buzz - tramadol for opiate addiction

    ReplyDelete
  58. buy tramadol online tramadol high yahoo - 100mg tramadol vs percocet

    ReplyDelete
  59. http://blog.dawn.com/dblog/buy/#85714 tramadol package insert - tramadol withdrawal oxycontin

    ReplyDelete
  60. http://ranchodelastortugas.com/#51462 much does generic xanax cost - generic xanax not working

    ReplyDelete