Which / That [chat]
"That" introduces essential clauses while "which" introduces nonessential clauses.
Essential clause: I like candy that is sweet.
Nonessential clause: I like candy which is delicious.
"That is sweet" is an essential clause. Since not all candy is sweet, the clause is essential to the reader's understanding of which category of candy one likes. Absent this clause, a reader could mistakenly think that one likes non-sweet candy.
"Which is delicious" is a nonessential clause. Since all candy is delicious, the clause "which is delicious" modifies all members of the category "candy" and indicates no essential information.
Except that one could define candy as "that which is sweet" and, so, the first clause would not be essential given that "is sweet" modifies all candy, under this understanding of candy. Furthermore, not all candy is delicious. Licorice, for example, is a candy which is not delicious. But...what if Licorice is, in fact, delicious and I have failed in my discernment of deliciousness? Or what if Licorice is not delicious, yet you think it is? So, "which is delicious" needs to be "that is delicious", given the possibility of candies...that are not delicious? ...which are not delicious? How would one know if all candies are sweet or delicious? Are sweetness or deliciousness subjective or objective qualities? What of candy? Is that which I call "candy" that which you call "candy"? Whence "candy-ness" and does "candy-ness" contain sweetness or deliciousness?
OH FUCKS!!!
4 comments:
We don't normally drink on the bridge.
Well, I don't normally fly on the Hindenberg 2.0.
And Cyril doesn't normally storm off without even kissing me goodbye.
So, we're all out of our comfort zone.
I just like slapping people who smoke in the sky.
..... Have you considered just how important active/passive voice is to the stuff you pore over?
Also, Licorice is always delicious, and anyone who says otherwise can not be trusted. I mean, its a flavor that can numb the tongue w/ its deliciousness.
To wit, your tastebuds cannot repel delicious of that magnitude.
I always spend the whole week thinking I am going to address the [chat] topic, but always forgetting and never taking the time to stop and smell the roses.
Post a Comment