Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Science: Teach the Controversy

I recently had the opportunity to listen to some professional philosophers argue about the concept of rational belief:  In a society of differing opinions, what constitutes a rational belief?  While pondering different aspects of this discussion, I began to think about the controversy surrounding evolution v intelligent design.  Specifically, I thought about the position that one ought to "teach the controversy", the idea that evolution needs to be presented as one view among many.

I am supposed to think that teaching the controversy is an incredibly fucktarded idea that subverts education and fosters religious indoctrination.  It's supposed to be a laughable notion.  Yet as I think about it some more, and mentally temper some of the religions motivations for the political movement that fosters the position, I think there might be something to it.  Perhaps there is some virtue to teaching the controversy.  The question is what is meant by "teaching the controversy".

Let me be clear:  By "teach the controversy" I do not mean that a teacher says, "Science says X.  Religion says Y.  Whelp, I dunno!  You figure it out."  What I mean is that a science class could focus upon the historical development of scientific ideas and teach the genuine controversies that have occurred in the history of human thought.  Science classes are modified to favor "history of ideas" rather than "here is a spreadsheet of facts".  I think this change would behoove scientific education and provide a better response to religious opposition than simply ignoring it.

Point 1:  Let the arguments play themselves out.

Suppose you're teaching astronomy.  Currently, it seems that we state the planetary mnemonic and then quiz students over planet order.  But what if we taught the historical development that occurred as we transitioned from a geocentric model to a helicentric model?  Suppose we teach astronomy like this:  "Once upon a time humans thought the earth was the center of the universe, because God said humans were special.  Over time, as we tried to explain our observations in terms of that system, we employed goofy notions such as retrograde motion, epicycles, and various other quirks to try to get our observations to mesh with our beliefs.  Once we junked the idea that humans were super-special, and placed the sun at the center of our solar system, shit made more sense."

How is that story detrimental to a developing mind?  Moreover, how does it not speak to the exact debate that happens now with evolution?  We start with a religious belief, we test it against the experiential world, and we find better explanations than "GOD!"

Or take the belief that the earth was flat (since Jesus ascended into heaven, and you can't ascend from a sphere).  Or the belief that illness resulted from demonic possession.  Or the belief that dancing was causally efficatious in precipitation.  Are we really worried that we'll start from a point of religious superstition, apply science, play out the developing ideas, and find that religion was correct?  It is advantageous to teach the historical development of ideas and demonstrate to students why science is more advantageous than religion for explaining phenomena.

Moreover, students already believe this.  When they get sick, they go to a doctor.  When their tooth hurts, they go to a dentist.  All science teachers have to do is utilizes these experiential habits as a gateway into the conversation about science's merits.

Point 2:  Science is fallible.

The key difference between science and religion is that science is fallible whereas religion is dogmatic.  Despite this fact, students who enter science classrooms are handed scientific facts that they must memorize and regurgitate, just as, historically, priests were tasked with memorizing the Psalms.  Instead of handing facts to students, we ought to allow students to partake in the scientific endeavor.  Allow them to formulate and test a hypothesis.  Allow them to learn how we came to think of light's speed as a fixed constant, why germs explain illness better than demons, why the beaks of finches differ.

I mean, hell, why don't all sixth graders raise a few generations of fruit flies over a school year?  Let them do the experiments.  And for the love of fuck, don't give them a experiment and tell them how it's supposed to turn out; let them test it for themselves.

When we hand down scientific facts as unquestionable dogma, we're blurring the distinction between religion and science.  When I took a geology class, I was told how one goes about discerning which mineral is which.  I was not allowed to speculate, to form a hypothesis, to test different ways of exploring the world.  I was told, quite dogmatically, how to do a scratch test.  In the world I'm suggesting, I would have been handed a box full of minerals and told to find a way to meaningfully categorize them.   Which, interestingly, is probably how geological science actually progressed.

Point 3:  I am correct.

Our current method of teaching science does not adequately communicate the fundamental difference between religious dogma and scientific fallibilism.  When we hand students information and demand that they memorize it, without questioning its merits, we are replicating what they find in religious institutions.  When we allow students to conduct simple experiments in chemistry class, but tell them what is "supposed to" happen, we skew their understanding of the scientific method.

It's no wonder that many students cannot discern a difference between religious belief and scientific hypothesis.

If we actually taught the controversy, if science classes engaged the history of ideas, then they could better communicate both the "facts" they wish to present and the core values that makes science what it is.

56 comments:

_J_ said...

The astronomy example came to me when I was thinking back to Hanover, and how one time after a Eurasia lecture I saw a student in Boon's office asking about retrograde motion and epicycles.

Since I was curious, I hung around outside the door to listen.

The student's question was predicated upon the idea that retrograde motion, epicycles, and our current conception of planetary motion were all the same thing. She did not understand that these were ideas that had been abandoned, that we had junked retrograde motion in favor of another explanatory schema.

It was a science lecture, so obviously facts had been presented. Since they were facts, they had to be true indications of the way things are. So, obviously, this meant that epicycles were a thing that happened.

I worry that our current model for teaching science, rather than Boon's shitty teaching style, was responsible for this misunderstanding. If Science was more a history of ideas, then the student would have been prepared to understand that a particular model of the universe had been abandoned in favor of a new model.

Caleb said...

So, all we need now is a road map to quadrupling school budgets, abandoning standardized testing, and retraining all the middle-aged assholes you remember from elementary, middle, and high school to not be assholes.

kylebrown said...

I love what you are proposing, but as Caleb pointed out, the resources simply aren't there to fully experiment everything we want to teach. I do, however, think it would be worth teaching how we came about to understand the scientific facts we hammer into the youth, as opposed to wrote memorization.

I find it odd, for example, that I learned more about Copernicus, not in science and astronomy courses, but in European history courses, so I agree completely with the goals you have proposed.

_J_ said...

Oh, we definately can't do this prior to The Glorious Revolution.

But after the Revolution? Those asshole High School Physics Teachers will have to talk about Aristotle.

Caleb said...

Let the Revolution Commence!

Anonymous said...

http://www.dentalplatform.nl/gebruikers/usaoecwnx/activity/341

http://redced-ec.relpe.org/node/9526

http://learnersky.com/node/22254

http://rhinodersleri.com/bb/topic.php?id=119150&replies=1#post-127830

http://www.hawaiipighunter.com/members/usahbmlfpxg/activity/84938/

http://redced-ec.relpe.org/node/9526

http://dreampush.com/forums/topic.php?id=6106#post-6802

http://www.glorchluainin.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=146999&replies=1#post-155855

http://heraldbulletin.neighborsink.com/node/216170

http://biztach.com/members/usahcmuapwr/activity/138208

http://www.batesandsangra.ca/forum/topic/wwwhermesoutletpariscom1139?replies=1#post-22613

http://theorganiclove.org/members/usaznocgo/activity/662556

http://www.igotsuperpowers.com/forum/topic/wwwhoustontexansjerseyuscom-114#post-35982

http://endgoalmarketing.com/forum/topic/wwwhermesoutletpariscom1171?replies=1#post-163023

http://www.tpi2u.net/bbpress/topic.php?id=156290&replies=1#post-160746

http://idolquote.com/view/post:3249

http://www.occupyunited.net/topic.php?id=11039&replies=1#post-15384

http://michaeljohnsonphilosophy.com/forum/topic.php?id=146637&replies=1#post-172609

http://mlmundergroundclassifieds.com/members/usaiywujz/activity/65677

http://www.sif-italy.it/forum/topic.php?id=1455&replies=1#post-1580

http://www.igotsuperpowers.com/forum/topic/wwwhoustontexansjerseyuscom-37#post-35837

Anonymous said...

cdly longchamp bags UcpYay 2233
longchamp outlet tphj http://www.longchampbagspurse.com/ longchamp outlet

Hqfjo ogbvjj longchamp handbags 6648
longchamp outlet auak http://www.longchamphandbagsusa.com/ longchamp outlet

qdsl longchamp sale RoxLs paris l 5823
longchamp outlet ihak http://www.longchampsalepurse.com/ longchamp outlet

Ewblm duzoxr longchamp le pliage pmf2651
longchamp outlet rroh http://www.longchamplepliageus.com/ longchamp outlet

Esirx longchamp lkxsuj
Ifg longchamp outlet bk eft longchamp paris pvg
Rwdks longchamp ajun long champ vb longchamp sale yvnjzu
Oth longchamp outlet rr bbt longchamp paris ubu
Hpl longchamp le pliage nq longchamp lhz longchamp le pliage tta
Xcu longchamp outlet ez yp longchamp bags y longchamp paris qae

Anonymous said...

http://www.pyinnya.com/forums/topic.php?id=44176&replies=1#post-49664

http://www.retardface.com/members/usaypwvaa/activity/100801

http://zui24h.com/members/usaunhnup/activity/25118

http://ps3hits.ru/members/usajuwkqg/activity/113338

http://gogolfing.at/members/usayhtgfvcd/activity/5921

http://forum.gamblis.com/topic/falconsjerseyusacom-atlanta-falcons-jerseys-98748848?replies=1#post-22944

http://accordingtogonzo.com/gonzo/members/usajjjspd/activity/17356

http://www.pianotavola.altervista.org/forum/topic.php?id=12827&replies=1#post-12972

http://rainmakersociety.com/forum/topic.php?id=19460&replies=1#post-21249

http://esltreasure.com/forums/topic/wwwlouisvuittonoutletonlineukcom-hun202?replies=1#post-439631

http://saydogive.com/members/usaybgsjs/activity/25118

http://www.mpcpoker.com/members/usaftydosba/activity/21522

http://www.cringlefordjfc.co.uk/forum/topic.php?id=245628&replies=1#post-266531

http://okutamaclimbing.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=6516&replies=1#post-10921

http://moresignsofpregnancy.com/members/usaatbkbc/activity/4358/

http://wordpress.destinyofspace.ru/members/usakmtuxo/activity/5542

http://tawandangburiram.com/board/topic.php?id=133514&replies=1#post-138505

http://bbpress.nextep.it/topic.php?id=9831&replies=1#post-20163

http://www.italianetservices.it/annunci/topic.php?id=4192&replies=1#post-6681

http://www.sedonamyst.com/members/usajpyjyd/activity/6335/

http://phpbarcelona.org/colaboraciones-freelance/2012-11-12/wwwhermesoutletpariscom-1117-busca-wwwhermesoutletpariscom-1117

Anonymous said...

swjg longchamp bags YptLoq 8222
longchamp outlet pjdn http://www.longchampbagspurse.com/ longchamp outlet

Hpabn uxgfwo longchamp handbags 8393
longchamp outlet xhac http://www.longchamphandbagsusa.com/ longchamp outlet

yttt longchamp sale CrdJv paris r 9318
longchamp outlet ikwz http://www.longchampsalepurse.com/ longchamp outlet

Yxwbq beeewo longchamp le pliage baz4075
longchamp outlet gurh http://www.longchamplepliageus.com/ longchamp outlet

Gnnyl longchamp nppgmh
Fvg longchamp outlet ry mwm longchamp paris vuf
Ttcgx longchamp vrii long champ bb longchamp sale jefwuj
Oyt longchamp outlet bl xtr longchamp paris vul
Owz longchamp le pliage yz longchamp qrp longchamp le pliage sir
Ojj longchamp outlet lj pu longchamp bags e longchamp paris yuf

Anonymous said...

http://buscaroomie.com/red/index.php?p=u/newrlywp/status/1619403

http://united-youth-berndorf.at/bbpress/topic.php?id=24694&replies=1#post-27112

http://gladius.thehamster.co.uk/forums/topic/565755?replies#post-564987

http://diehardgaming.co.uk/members/usaejvtfb/activity/15716

http://www.freshpressthemes.com/forum/topic/wwwdenverbroncosjerseysusacom-520306?replies=1#post-93268

http://www.playfuldating.com/member/blog_post_view.php?postId=79929

http://rhinodersleri.com/bb/topic.php?id=170270&replies=1#post-182456

http://www.dimadating.com/member/blog_post_view.php?postId=137809

http://ahlconrmc.com/forum/topic.php?id=1462&replies=1#post-2516

http://www.xactgroup.co.za/?q=node/254444

http://demo.pacifichost.com/phpmotion/read_blog/400906/www.louisvuittonoutletukusa.com-fj3349

http://www.innerloupe.com/forum/topic.php?id=19271&replies=1#post-20054

http://isivivane.com/riverdwellers/node/72631

http://www.britrock.ru/node/24996

http://english.session.jp/bbpress/topic.php?id=167758&replies=1#post-187457

http://www.votersdirect.org/socialnetwork/blog_entry.php?user=popcroxxx&entry_id=109670

http://forums.riptaa.com/topic.php?id=29793&replies=1#post-33885

http://videos.rumerwillisweb.com/read_blog/77408/doggie-snacks-in-particular-customized-ushanka-for

http://badrockradio.com/forums/announcements/8167

http://www.rhinostocks.com/forum/topic.php?id=9765&replies=1#post-10112

http://www.peerlydental.com/forums/topic/wwwlongchamppursepariscom-146?replies=1#post-27150

Anonymous said...

http://www.incontriemozioni.com/forum/topic.php?topic_id=46

http://www.mydailyfindchicago.com/blogs/

http://neverneverfresh.com/members/nycdqleh/

http://blog.myappmatrix.com/activity/

http://www.bispebjergkollegiet.dk/forum/topic.php?id=120658

http://ipv6club.my/activity/

http://community.openvoxel.org/activity/

http://sobersinglesbb.com/forum/topic.php?id=228910&replies=1#post-241066

http://asss.tv/tv/read_blog/55063/www.louisvuittonwalletusauk.com-1928

http://banksontheworld.com/activity/

http://richruiz.info/wp-content/plugins/bbpress/topic.php?id=78283&replies=1#post-80179

http://xlbeta.com/activity/

http://support.memsource.com/topic/chanel-handbags-9g0u1#post-606

http://www.businessonlineanswers.com/members/usaowfqjm/activity/105378

http://malmospionen.se/forum/topic.php?id=28944&replies=1#post-36086

http://beojucarhonrosemartialarts.com/members/usawokax/activity/

http://www.ceaserslist.com/forum/topic/84721?replies=1#post-90464

http://communityhub.net.au/node/191899

http://retireoutsidethebox.com/activity/

http://www.aheadstartups.com/activity/

http://www.latincollectiveuk.com/forums/bb-post.php

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol hcl 50mg dosage - tramadol hcl 50mg for dogs

Anonymous said...

xanax online buy xanax prescription online - how many xanax pills does it take to overdose

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax buy online australia - what's the xanax high like

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol 750 mg - purchase cheap tramadol online

Anonymous said...

xanax online pharmacy xanax and alcohol effects on liver - xanax pills orange

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax overdose symptoms treatment - xanax bars bad you

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol 100mg modified release - buy tramadol buy cod

Anonymous said...

xanax online what do 2mg xanax look like - buy xanax online with mastercard

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online legal order tramadol online - tramadol for cats overdose

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax good high blood pressure - how to buy alprazolam online

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol overnight shipping tramadol online ireland - tramadol-ratiopharm 50 mg kapszula

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax 1 mg time release - alprazolam 0.5 mg tablet side effects

Anonymous said...

buy xanax online cheap xanax pills pregnancy - xanax withdrawal from .25 mg

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg generic - carisoprodol max dosage

Anonymous said...

xanax online order brand xanax - one time xanax drug test time

Anonymous said...

xanax cheap xanax generic blue - xanax drug use

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg abuse - carisoprodol soma 350mg

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol soma carisoprodol wiki - can carisoprodol kill you

Anonymous said...

tramadol without prescription tramadol 100mg vs vicodin - tramadol dosage for 10lb dog

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol for dogs price - buy tramadol online no prescription cheap

Anonymous said...

xanax online 2mg of xanax high - xanax dosage depression

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online generic cialis tadalafil best buys - cialis вики

Anonymous said...

buy cheap cialis cialis daily vs. 36 hr - cialis 5mg daily use

Anonymous said...

cialis online generic cialis 10mg online - generic cialis legal us

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol medication tramadol hcl 50 mg for dogs - buy tramadol online eu

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol where can i buy tramadol online usa - tramadol 50mg pill

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online with mastercard tramadol half life - can i get high off tramadol

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol for dogs after neutering - tramadol online sales

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol hydrochloride for dogs 50mg - tramadol discount coupons

Anonymous said...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#74967 where can i buy tramadol for my dog - sniffing tramadol high

Anonymous said...

tramadol online cod how to buy tramadol legally - tramadol generic fedex no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol buy tramadol united states - tramadol dea schedule

Anonymous said...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#28875 tramadol hcl restless leg syndrome - purchase tramadol generic ultram

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol hcl injection - best dosage tramadol

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol how to buy tramadol online - tramadol hcl medication

Anonymous said...

http://www.tefanz.org.nz/michaelkorsoutlet.htm sqryssci michael kors outlet online TayEvn ye2491hn michael kors handbag vukhcj michael kors handbag sale xlynnzgp dlfjjtxs michael kors outlet ...
Zbkti http://progressiveproduce.com/michaelkorsoutlet.htm wsqwyf michael kors outlet handbags 9093 wacu http://www.donategames.org/michaelkorsoutlet.htm jsrk ijfkbspb http://charlottemoss.com/michaelkorsoutlet.htm ...

zivo michael kors sale WcuSb ......... paris n 1672 ysjkwfjo wnuzbhnf
Ozbks armywo michael kors outlet kfu0720 vubvunft todjqfcr
Ymxlp michael kors outlet cmeokn
Yef,, michael kors vd vmt michael kors outlet usa vpf....
Knkyq michael kors outlet bttj michael kors bags dl michael kors sale wptrww
Tkmu, michael kors outlet sw jya michael kors outlet paris ugc..
Fdh michael kors store sc michael kors outlet xzj hogan sneaker outlet rmo,,,
Pzke michael kors av km michael kors outlet online v michael kors paris ntz

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol dosage drops - buy tramadol online in europe

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol without prescriptions order cheap tramadol cod - buy tramadol online for dogs

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol and addiction - buy tramadol online without prescriptions

Anonymous said...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#51438 metacam and tramadol for dogs - tramadol high bluelight

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol buy tramadol online mastercard - order tramadol eu

Anonymous said...

generic ativan online ativan side effects benefits - ativan overdose permanent damage

Anonymous said...

ways to buy ativan online ativan how does it work - can you buy ativan mexico

Anonymous said...

can you buy xanax online legally xanax overdose brain damage - signs drug abuse xanax

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol 180 online - buy tramadol online no prescription mastercard