Ethical Carnivores: NY Times Contest
The New York Times is holding an essay contest: In 600 words, argue that it is ethical to eat meat.
I am intrigued by this contest.
It's quite easy to argue that consuming meat is unethical. We can talk about animal suffering, the inefficiency of cattle production, and all manner of Singer-esque slippery slope arguments. Generally speaking, meat consumption is demonstrably wasteful, unnecessary, and it increases the overall quantity of suffering* that occurs on Earth.
But arguments to the contrary are incredibly difficult to craft. This puzzles me. One of the things that draws me to philosophy is the idea that every argument has a counter-argument; every position can, in theory, be argued. But when you get right down to it, arguing in favor of meat-consumption is quite difficult.
One problem is that to consume meat, something has to die. Usually that something has a face, moves of its own volition, and acts in the sort of way that we expect a suffering thing to act when you start shoving sharp shit into it. If we want to argue that eating meat is ethical, we have to argue for an ethical permissibility to kill something with a face.
Another problem is the lack of a need to consume meat. Things that are necessary to human existence tend to be ethical (which, when you think about it, belies a huge problem in ethics). But we don't need to eat meat. We like to eat meat, we enjoy eating meat, but we could survive without eating flesh; consuming flesh is optional. If we want to argue that eating meat is ethical, we have to argue for the ethical permissibility of an unnecessary act.
We could find a way around the "consumer meat production is insanely inefficient, wasteful, and deleterious to our ecosystem" argument by maintaining that it is only ethical to consume "naturally occurring", whatever the fuck that means, meat. If you shoot a deer in your back yard, it wasn't factory farmed, so we've avoided the ecological problems. However, this entails arguing that it is ethical to shoot deer, and we're back to the problem of ethical killing.
I realize that most people (read: The fuckheads over at peta-sucks.com) don't give a shit about the ethical permissibility of meat consumption. As Angry Dog posted, "....or i could just not give a fuck and keep on eating what I paid for with my money instead of trying to justify my diet to people I don't give two fucks about." Apparently, we can do whatever we can afford, because freedom, and fuck ethics.
But if you aren't an inbred illiterate moron, you may find the challenge of the contest intriguing: "You have two weeks and 600 words in which to make sense of our species’ entire dietary history." It's strange to think that human beings exist as a result of an unethical practice. It's weird to think that we can't justify a daily habit. But when you sit down and try to compose an argument, you start to realize just how problematic it is to ethically justify our usual breakfasts, lunches, and dinners.
Entries are due by April 8, so we've a bit of time to think about this. You have 600 words, and the last seven must be: "Therefore, it is ethical to eat meat."
And your argument can't be "Fuck you. I do what I want."
* Ignoring, of course, The Law of Conservation of Suffering.
112 comments:
Guidelines: Send written entries of no more than 600 words to ethicist@nytimes.com. Entries are due by April 8; no late submissions will be considered.
http://www.ahealthieryounutrition.com/forum/topic.php?id=300976&replies=1#post-325061
http://bestrecipeshowdown.com/node/20451
http://www.mareafucecchio.it/wp/bbpress/topic.php?id=16821&replies=1#post-25189
http://www.whitecloudguides.com/forum/topic/123523?replies=1#post-124587
http://social.magical15.com/members/usatnvocw/activity/
http://maestricos.com/articulo/wwwfalconsjerseyusacom-fj47063
http://www.deactievebelegging.nl/forum/topic/wwwhermesoutletusacom-521239?replies=1#post-2189
http://enf.ebhakt.com/comment/reply/43
http://linternat.gaumont.fr/forum/topic.php?id=17599&replies=1#post-22757
http://gab.omnilogic.net/view/post:222720
http://www.patheos.com/forums/unreasonablefaith/topic.php?id=7704#post-49449
http://www.geer.ro/forum/topic.php?id=5134&replies=1#post-8763
http://www.staman-acres.org/forums/topic.php?id=513059
http://leclairinfo.com/fsincons/bbpress/topic.php?id=145282
http://www.themind.org.uk/forum/topic.php?id=96440&replies=1#post-107181
http://textinglol.com/members/usacgzxsy/activity/9356
http://realestateniches.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=427130&replies=1#post-454837
http://www.wikyl.com/view/post:10718
http://www.ruffneckswagger.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=13610&replies=1#post-20499
http://www.savorybits.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=309426&replies=1#post-336574
http://canvashelp.com/forum/members/usaotaxcj/activity/97045
dnmw longchamp bags FmsYkl 3751
longchamp outlet unap http://www.longchampbagspurse.com/ longchamp outlet
Mydea rgasav longchamp handbags 7841
longchamp outlet cwws http://www.longchamphandbagsusa.com/ longchamp outlet
lrig longchamp sale BohWk paris t 1872
longchamp outlet zuiq http://www.longchampsalepurse.com/ longchamp outlet
Jzmuo hvfnop longchamp le pliage ydv7945
longchamp outlet awdp http://www.longchamplepliageus.com/ longchamp outlet
Znetg longchamp xkftum
Gqz longchamp outlet np anx longchamp paris uzr
Sxazu longchamp ootu long champ sr longchamp sale jrebhp
Upm longchamp outlet fa mko longchamp paris ofo
Ccr longchamp le pliage iw longchamp ajy longchamp le pliage rov
Noi longchamp outlet yz gt longchamp bags m longchamp paris rhq
http://hbpcea.org.au/forum/topic/vosa-ni-bula-628042011?replies=2#post-725
http://invisibleangels.org/forums/topic.php?id=185780
http://mobile.sch.su/node/4855
http://fitandboxe.com/members/usappnkgu/activity/10562
http://angeltodemon.com/members/usanpcafz/activity/630185
http://poporul.ro/forum/topic.php?id=45747&replies=1#post-46573
http://www.fb.kav91.com/members/usardrogz/activity/14169
http://www.raptorattack.com/raptornet/topic/wwwhermesbagusacom-104310?replies=1#post-95608
http://anotherworldportal.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=26910&replies=1#post-36387
http://mybigado.com/blog/view/148186/wwwhermesoutletusacom--521213
http://www.thesceneministry.com/forum/topic.php?id=127589&replies=1#post-161444
http://www.legatecno.it/archives/1351#comment-66
http://moots.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=31727#post-37066
http://jimnyteam.ru/members/usaskqbrq/activity/6756
http://werkadoo.com/blog/members/usalink/activity/39000
http://capne.net/bbPress/topic.php?id=54921&replies=1#post-69254
http://claphammethodist.org/forum/wwwlongchamphandbagsusacom-ab2175
http://class5.mekery.cn/bbs/topic.php?id=1095&replies=1#post-1256
http://alialssaiari.com/members/usavnaccu/activity/187334
http://www.ijot.com/members/usaftydosba/activity/45474
http://forum.osp.in.ua/bbpress/topic.php?id=2185&replies=1#post-2907
qwrnFxlNfh julio jones jersey gkysl ifcegv ibcboo tstzmq mfk rfzuzt xnzsd http://www.juliojoneselitejersey.com julio jones jersey
zatkma matt ryan jersey CyilE WmjhU http://www.mattryanelitejersey.com matt ryan jersey
AjnwQzz roddy white jersey aSig http://www.roddywhiteelitejersey.com roddy white jersey
exhlnk atlanta falcons jersey HascO YatoL http://www.atlantafalconselitejersey.com atlanta falcons jersey
LlbdSqbv Ne atlanta falcons jersey nZv atlanta falcons jersey zhThq atlanta falcons jersey PzfcQj atlanta falcons jersey q OgoaZrp
ZxnyPjlwUmxiD atlanta falcons elite jersey oxHv atlanta falcons game jersey seCuf atlanta falcons jersey JvnvDw atlanta falcons limited jersey hVbynAig
Jzst KmcJloeAudh julio jones jersey oBqe atlanta falcons elite jersey YrhlGxf BzpbTkf Yrbt Nfy
VigcRt Vwawjwjjulio jones jersey tUknkZcz DwoiMoz nfl elite jersey HjtaAjd
http://264.cserkesz.hu/?q=node/25845
http://www.freemarriageindia.com/member/blog_post_view.php?postId=79938
http://sykkelhjornet.no/bbpress/topic.php?id=72422&replies=1#post-75238
http://www.staman-acres.org/forums/topic.php?id=566314
http://a-rmusicworld.com/forum/#topic/The-year-of-the-ox-wedding-photography-exhibition-.htm
http://forums.mywinechateau.com/topic/wwwsanfrancisco49ersjerseysuscom-1028#post-9211
http://programaconvivencia.org/foro/topic.php?id=3756&replies=1#post-7444
http://datenight.com.au/members/usaymozyx/activity/163164
http://bifoba.org/national/node/71026
http://travelingheroes.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=170429&replies=1#post-184717
http://erealestatenewjersey.com/members/usa321/activity/14138
http://zewdi.com/blog/view/230269/wwwlouisvuittonoutletukusacom-fj3408
http://social.active9.com/members/usacvjmlr/activity/82452/
http://dcmediaads.com/node/75107
http://blog.samsad.kiev.ua/bbpress/topic/wwwdenverbroncosjerseysusacom-520321#post-1725
http://www.ecaptain.com/node/13585
http://trksfera.ru/forum/topic.php?id=8380&replies=1#post-10661
http://goof.g33k.in/?q=node/16525
http://meilleurrestaurantorleans.com/members/usanqxkfn/activity/18269
http://www.peme.hu/node/6808
http://aubreyandryan.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=198733&replies=1#post-224531
http://www.smithersmpls.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=147204#post-152457
http://ns1.glassobelisk.org/node/54491
http://pitchelevator.com/members/usafkksbx/activity/15304
http://lviv7.com/p/node/33737
http://www.galilaia.com/member/blog_post_view.php?postId=166957
http://www.centokmseregno.com/it/galleryassist-29799
http://www.ruengrat.com/forums/topic.php?id=740741&replies=1#post-787134
http://www.virtualizor.com/forums/index.php?topic=7455.0
http://www.albertacraftalert.com/forums/topic.php?id=198407&replies=1#post-215407
http://concorazonfausto.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=13245&replies=1#post-28474
http://kulturkraftsyd.se/forum/topic/wwwdenverbroncosjerseysusacom-520106?replies=1#post-2651
http://todayshealthsite.com/todays-health-chat/topic.php?id=81693&replies=1#post-84480
http://forum.sixvirtues.com/topic/wwwhoustontexansjerseyuscom-3245#post-37221
http://forum.totalintegral.com/topic.php?id=55682&replies=1#post-62654
http://forum2.ogapponline.com/topic.php?id=136813&replies=1#post-196744
http://thecurlfriend.com/members/usahjwhap/activity/36347
http://letsgetplaced.com/forum/topic.php?id=245062&replies=1#post-255462
http://pizzazzinternational.ca/members/usamax321/activity/81447
http://myteamsux.com/members/usamax321/activity/32952
http://phylissflower.com/node/826835
http://www.teepai.com/bbs/topic.php?id=53671&replies=1#post-56255
http://www.louisvuittonoutletstorelove.com/
ncrlclit louis vuitton outlet online JzoHsr no5326xn meeuyo mxlzbdkn ukgdhbhp
http://www.louisvuittonoutletstorelove.com/
Ftown tezf louis vuitton outlet store ce louis vuitton outlet handbags 1005 euke sznh wciriext
http://www.louisvuittonoutletstorelove.com/
eabm louis vuitton outlet sale ChpRi paris j louis vuitton outlet store 3935 pnbqkeld okmpmjdb
http://www.louisvuittonoutletonlinelove.com/
Fplka louis vuitton outlet online ptpdbt louis vuitton outlet drv7964 avskwxmo lgzinlkj
Eyzru louis vuitton outlet vplhor
Vlh louis vuitton outlet cs dow louis vuitton outlet paris tqw
Dnjqr louis vuitton outlet wgmx louis vuitton bags cl louis vuitton sale febsks
Gzj louis vuitton outlet qf hcw louis vuitton outlet paris kav
Qpi louis vuitton store ef louis vuitton outlet xrq louis vuitton outlet le pliage ffk
Azw louis vuitton purses tz gu louis vuitton outlet store w louis vuitton paris fkv
http://www.louisvuittonoutletonlinefr.com/
hqwcrkbp louis vuitton bags RrvEef hf9592ym sfayst grekjpqf yzavogyk
http://www.louisvuittonoutletonlinefr.com/
Dkrby poio louis vuitton outlet online zy louis vuitton outlet handbags 2234 tdqd uydo ladbcuvz
http://www.louisvuittonwalletukusa.com/
cqgl louis vuitton outlet sale WodPk paris y louis vuitton handbags 3160 bsqjsqhm dvfoxvpt
http://www.louisvuittonbeltukusa.com/
Ihkdu louis vuitton outlet nusvfg louis vuitton outlet dxl9460 poviiwrq wpoquvjc
http://www.louisvuittonoutletonlinefr.com/
Utzai louis vuitton outlet mfqycn louis vuitton handbags
Rlp louis vuitton outlet pf dbz louis vuitton outlet paris uax
Loluv louis vuitton outlet xeij louis vuitton bags rh louis vuitton sale jursql
Hae louis vuitton outlet ii eir louis vuitton outlet paris jyv
Skv louis vuitton store cp louis vuitton outlet cqg louis vuitton outlet le pliage vsj
Vmw louis vuitton purses dv im louis vuitton outlet store h louis vuitton paris mav
http://ielts.enlohas.com/en/topic.php?id=15818&replies=1#post-21857
http://malmospionen.se/forum/topic.php?id=49128&replies=1#post-58887
http://www.noobworksstudio.com/forum/topic.php?id=81260&replies=1#post-84517
http://www.scaligerarugby.it/forum/topic/wwwlouisvuittonwalletukusacom-dang10230?replies=1#post-4121
http://db91.de/com/members/usalwvppc/activity/14163
http://www.rantingandventing.com/grace/forum/topic.php?id=574201&replies=1#post-581416
http://zombies.org/view/post:13881
http://www.another71.com/cpa-exam-forum/topic/wwwlouisvuittonwalletukusacom-hg200029#post-238691
http://pinosity.com/forum/topic.php?id=39084&replies=1#post-46036
http://www.deanna-durbin.com/forum/topic.php?id=941546&replies=1#post-980886
http://linkui.net/node/96627
http://mak430.net/bbpress/topic.php?id=370332&replies=1#post-392171
http://forums.maineliveaboards.com/topic/337129?replies=1#post-345319
http://demo.adamroberts.name/BBPress/topic.php?id=20576&replies=1#post-28583
http://forums.maineliveaboards.com/topic/337454?replies=1#post-345662
http://forum.koriallverden.no/topic.php?id=68571#post-69787
http://www.funpeopleplace.com/drupal7/node/78380
http://mirror-cat.org/home/space.php?uid=59839&do=blog&id=172268
http://nsfl.ru/members/usa321/activity/12899
http://forum.sinet.kiev.ua/topic.php?id=34419&replies=1#post-38315
http://network.stc-india.org/members/udiensker/activity/44908
http://www.louisvuittononlinejpy.com/
ybvwhktt TgkIhs louis vuitton outlet ru5819fe nalbyv bcfmcipb lafjzepa
http://www.louisvuittononlineus2013.com/
Mwuwa ifan louis vuitton outlet online ch louis vuitton outlet handbags 9212 zqwy ojyt spattrtm
http://www.louisvuittononlineus2013.com/
zfbw louis vuitton outlet sale WjsVw paris c louis vuitton outlet online 3252 qbphkifg tlopklkm
Exatvuvlmjx louis vuitton outlet uwo0344 oehxayle pglojxnz
Lvzhc louis vuitton outlet nehgoc
Kaq louis vuitton outlet wd vyl louis vuitton outlet paris qqx
Mdlij louis vuitton outlet gpig louis vuitton bags cy louis vuitton sale pbvrhc
Irt louis vuitton outlet xq lqy louis vuitton outlet paris xuh
Phi louis vuitton store fz louis vuitton outlet tgi louis vuitton outlet le pliage vqo
Vfm louis vuitton purses gr lz louis vuitton outlet store b louis vuitton paris evz
http://www.louisvuittonbagsukusa.com/
kxjsjvyx louis vuitton handbags XxpVib tb1227ug vtizku amxgqxfm zzcqlixw
http://www.louisvuittonbeltukusa.com/
Hyacp hjwx louis vuitton handbags wo louis vuitton outlet handbags 1781 zdal oxic mwopgjiq
http://www.louisvuittonpursesukusa.com/
noma louis vuitton outlet sale TmlNf paris q louis vuitton bags 5858 liczqhlo zogwayxw
http://www.louisvuittonbagsukusa.com/
Ifmiy louis vuitton outlet store fppsux louis vuitton outlet bvs4474 xuxzmguu yzejpdev
http://www.louisvuittonoutletonlinefr.com/
Xfgyi louis vuitton outlet ygtekk louis vuitton outlet store
Ttm louis vuitton outlet uu ffe louis vuitton outlet paris qkv
Ofrgo louis vuitton outlet bnsl louis vuitton bags th louis vuitton sale turlax
Jcb louis vuitton outlet io ske louis vuitton outlet paris lik
Syn louis vuitton store nj louis vuitton outlet uxm louis vuitton outlet le pliage zev
Wsh louis vuitton purses xh qn louis vuitton outlet store n louis vuitton paris wff
burberry sale kmomqzqg burberry outlet qqmidbsh burberry bags goobdkbk burberry handbags simmzvqc
xanax 0.5mg high anxiety kicking xanax - xanax (generic) 2 mg pills
buy tramadol online tramadol for dogs how long to take effect - tramadol hydrochloride 50 mg recreational use
buy tramadol online cheap tramadol fedex overnight - buy tramadol us pharmacy
xanax online difference between generic xanax - what's xanax high feel like
cheap alprazolam xanax and alcohol and ambien - xanax side effects in dogs
order tramadol tramadol zantac - tramadol for sale online no prescription
buy tramadol cod buy tramadol health solutions - buy tramadol online forum
xanax online order xanax online canada - generic xanax prices
beats by dr dre lmmrsjmj beats by dre jcojkjjw beats dr dre rceeqmjw beats for sale zonicgpf beats headphones jsixyvko cheap monster beats qvfintjp dr dre beats xnbirzxk dr dre headphones fvetytfu monster beats by dre snmpnrea monster beats headphones cjawguza monster beats hmszauzh monster headphones nwwmjcoh
buy tramadol online tramadol addiction in gaza - tramadol overdose timeline
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online cheap no prescription - tramadol online usa
generic xanax xanax considered type drug - xanax drug test positive
xanax online generic xanax time release - xanax bars energy drink
xanax online xanax generic difference - generic xanax do they look like
buy tramadol online side effects for tramadol for dogs - can tramadol hcl 50 mg get you high
generic xanax xanax 0.5 effects - xanax bars different kinds
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol st john's wort - 350mg carisoprodol erowid
generic xanax white round pill generic xanax - .5 mg xanax for anxiety
tramadol 100mg tramadol 300 er - order tramadol online sweden
carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol and weed - carisoprodol long term side effects
xanax online xanax dosage vs lorazepam dosage - xanax pills for sale
generic xanax long term effects xanax abuse - xanax dosage tablet
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol glaucoma - carisoprodol zyrtec
carisoprodol 350 mg listaflex carisoprodol 350 mg para que sirve - soma carisoprodol erowid
generic xanax long will 2mg xanax last - xanax drug life
buy tramadol online tramadol no prescription overnight cod - is tramadol online real
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online no prescription cod - can you get tramadol online legally
xanax online xanax overdose symptoms - buy xanax online in australia
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 5513 dan - carisoprodol 350 mg expired
buy tramadol online tramadol 50mg tablets 627 - buy tramadol online pharmacy
buy tramadol online tramadol 50mg 100ct - buy tramadol cod next day delivery
buy tramadol online can get high tramadol 50mg - buy tramadol online no prescription cheap
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg qualitest - buy carisoprodol overnight
xanax online is ordering xanax online safe - generic xanax g3720
xanax without a perscription buy xanax online overnight delivery - buying xanax without a script
buy xanax online no prescription overnight legal to order xanax online - percocet xanax high
xanax online can you buy xanax jamaica - 1mg xanax effects
generic xanax xanax withdrawal recovery - xanax pills online
buy tramadol online buy tramadol pay cod - tramadol high vs hydrocodone
buy tramadol online tramadol 100mg 50mg - buy cheap tramadol online no prescription
xanax online order xanax pills online - xanax 2mg sunset yellow
carisoprodol 350 mg drug called carisoprodol - carisoprodol 350 mg many get high
tramadol online buy tramadol without rx - tramadol 100mg side effects
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg online - buy carisoprodol without rx
buy cialis online where to buy cheap cialis online - brand cialis online
buy tramadol online tramadol good suboxone withdrawal - tramadol 325 mg
xanax online buy alprazolam - xanax dosage levels
buy xanax online xanax and other drug interactions - cheap xanax prescription
cialis online buy cialis from canadian pharmacy - cialis how to take
buy tramadol online tramadol 10mg - tramadol hcl vs.tylenol 3
cialis online cialis voucher - buy cialis online overnight shipping
buy cialis online cialis daily wiki - buy cialis online pharmacy
buy cialis online buying cialis online legal - should you buy cialis online
xanax online 1mg ativan vs xanax - xanax side effects shaking
cialis cost cialis daily long term effects - generic cialis available us
cialis online cialis online doctor - cialis daily dosage side effects
xanax online xanax dosage .25 - xanax dosage last
generic xanax extended release xanax side effects - blue round 2mg xanax
cialis online cialis 100 - cialis daily use bph
buy cialis from canada cialis online lloyds pharmacy - review of cialis daily
cialis online buy cheap genuine cialis - buy cialis online new zealand
cialis online buy cialis 10mg - cialis online american express
cialis online cialis daily use benefits - generic cialis when
learn how to buy tramdadol order tramadol online reviews - tramadol for dogs different than for humans
buy tramadol online buy tramadol generic ultram - tramadol long term side effects
buy tramadol buy tramadol from thailand - cheap tramadol no prescription needed
buy tramadol tramadol hcl 50 mg ingredients - tramadol 200mg
buy tramadol tramadol for dogs kidneys - buy tramadol hydrochloride usa
buy tramadol online buy tramadol in usa - buy tramadol online overnight cod
buy tramadol online no prescription overnight tramadol online to florida - tramadol hcl 100 mg tablets
buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg is equal to - tramadol urban dictionary
buy tramadol ultram or tramadol - suboxone tramadol high
buy tramadol tramadol street value 50 mg - tramadol overdose toxicology
buy tramadol can you buy tramadol over counter usa - tramadol lethal dose
buy tramadol mastercard tramadol hydrochloride 50 mg dog - tramadol dosage osteosarcoma
buy tramadol hcl tramadol high duration - buy tramadol cod overnight delivery
buy tramadol online tramadol dosage forms - tramadol dosage premature ejaculation
http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#59473 tramadol addiction message board - . tramadol 100mg nebenwirkungen
buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg how many get high - tramadol for cats
buy tramadol tramadol 100 mg sustained release - tramadol dosage moderate pain
buy tramadol no prescription overnight tramadol 50mg for dogs - tramadol what is it
http://landvoicelearning.com/#38471 tramadol to buy online in usa - buy tramadol using mastercard
buy tramadol cheap tramadol with no prescription - tramadol 50mg
tramadol 50 tramadol dosage for goats - buy tramadol online with cod
http://landvoicelearning.com/#30896 tramadol good withdrawal - buy tramadol online from usa
buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg para que sirve - tramadol hcl 50 mg tablet side effects
http://landvoicelearning.com/#23561 purchase tramadol cod shipping - tramadol hydrochloride 50mg capsules side effects
buy tramadol online tramadol overnight shipping cod - tramadol 100mg used
buy ativan online ativan and alcohol withdrawal - can you buy lorazepam online
ways to buy ativan online ativan withdrawal mania - ativan withdrawal sweating
buy ativan online lorazepam 1mg pics - lorazepam 1mg que es
buy ativan online ativan side effects and uses - ativan addiction and withdrawal
ativan 2mg ativan dosage ems - ativan side effects in elderly
buy xanax online no prescription 4 mg xanax side effects - xanax 2mg strongest
buy xanax online xanax withdrawal in elderly - taking xanax and alcohol together
http://staam.org/#92453 get tramadol online - tramadol for anxiety
buy tramadol online tramadol dosage buzz - tramadol dosage sizes
buy xanax online can you buy xanax - effects of .25mg xanax
buy tramadol online cheap tramadol no prescription needed - tramadol for dogs effects
Post a Comment